It seems that the state of medical errors in this country has not changed much and in fact the US is leading the entire world in death by medical errors.
USA leads world in medical errors
The article states: ” Based on a comparison of health care systems in six nations, the 2005 Commonwealth Fund International Health Policy Survey found that America led the rest in inefficient care and medical errors.”
And continued with ” Based on a comparison of health care systems in six nations, the 2005 Commonwealth Fund International Health Policy Survey found that America led the rest in inefficient care and medical errors.
Improper Treatment 34 Percent of the Time
Researchers interviewed patients who had a serious condition that required intense medical treatment or had been admitted to a hospital for a condition other than a routine pregnancy.
Patients in this country received the wrong medication, inaccurate or delayed test results, and improper treatment 34 percent of the time.
A third of the patients polled reported higher rates of disorganized care in their physician’s offices.
Americans also spent more on medical expenses than those in the other countries, with more than half unable to see a doctor or take prescribed medicines.
The spread between the United States and countries with lower error rates was fairly wide, with a 12 percent difference between Britain, which had the lowest rate of errors, and the United States. The American rate was driven up by fairly frequent test and medication errors”
The above paragraphs are excepts of a subject treated more thorougly on those sites. In previous years our rate of death by medical error has exceeded the number of people killed by car accidents as I mentioned in a previous post.
Scarily, when doctors have gone on strike the death rate has actually
decreased. http://www.mercola.com/2004/may/26/doctors_death.htm
You would think that errors must occur when medical professionals are hard at work by themselves without an extra pair of hands or eyes to notice things are not as they should be. But even when someone is there and sees the wrong, they seldom say anything.
The following link demonstrates that when co-workers have observed medical errors in their co-workers they are reluctant to talk about them.
http://www.mercola.com/2005/feb/9/health_care_mistakes.htm
The article mentions:
“Some actions observed in the above study that co-workers and
supervisors did not address were:
Some instances health workers were reluctant to talk to their
colleagues about included matters concerning:
Competence
Broken rules
Mistakes
Teamwork
Lack of support
Disrespect and micromanagement from doctors or supervisors”
May states have put caps on malpractice awards that may be given and
those states see an influx of medical doctors.
http://www.ahrq.gov/research/tortcaps/tortcaps.htm
In some cases the only way to effect change is to legally slap the entity with a fine. But we are not going to be able to do that as often or as hard no matter how bad the situtation.
Medical errors cost the country 37 billion a year
http://www.ahrq.gov/qual/errback.htm
Complete with the rise in medical errors, this current administration
is proposing caps and cutting lawsuits against doctors for their
errors.
“The President is also proposing medical liability reforms. The costs
of medical liability insurance are driving doctors out of practice, or
are being passed on to patients and their employers in higher
insurance rates. In addition, the pressure of medical liability
lawsuits is causing more doctors to practice medicine defensively and
order more lab tests or exams than is necessary, which is driving up
health care costs even further. By enacting national medical liability
reform we will be able to address the problem of junk lawsuits against
doctors, clear our court system of unnecessary litigation, and help to
control health care inflation.”
So unless your problem is neat and observable, expect a less
compreshensive diagnosis and no recourse should your doctor kill or
maime you during his practice.
You might think that this really doesn’t matter. But let me interject with my story. Here is a list of over about the past ten years things that happend to my mother in hospitals and the various hospitals they happened in.
1995ish Westchester Medical Center Valhalla, New York. The roof is leaking. I walk in to find my mother’s bed in a pool of water, the controls for the bed and TV clipped to her nightgown, and lying in the pool of water, the power cords, plugged into the wall.
1995ish Westchester Medical Center Valhalla, New York
Nurse takes my diabetic mother’s blood sugar and tells her she does not need to take any insulin. Diabetics need insulin before a meal to keep their blood level stable.
November 2004 Westchester Medical Center
My mother entered the Westchester Medical Center in New York State for a simple test. One that used an iodine dye. She had previously known dye sensitivities. My mother had the angiogram at Westchester Medical Center and soon developed a fever and rashes on her skin. The rashes turned to blisters and daily her doctor, Dr. Cohen of the cardiac cath lab, would come in, look at the worsening skin and go “OH that looks better”. She asked for a dermatologist and the nurse told her she didn’t need one. Let’s remember she had previously known iodine dye sensitivities. Finally one came and took a skin sample which was never processed. She had an IV by this point and a friend who was also an RN noticed it was compromised and it took 24 hours to get it changed. She ended up crashing, painfully, the blisters on her legs breaking open, her kidney’s failing and was put in the burn unit where she then from the compromised IV developed septicemia.
2004 Westchester Medical Center Burn Center
They are amazed my mother is alive, so much of her skin has peeled off her body. In fact they have to take her to a shower table and peel the dead skin off her raw flesh. The table is shower table is motorized and the motor is broken so it is higher than my mother’s gurney. Two nurses cannot lift her that high and in trying slam her raw open skinnless flesh onto the higher table multiple times. I go to her room and find her bruised and crying in great pain.
2004 Westchester Medical Center Valhalla, New York
It’s Christmas Eve. Everyone is snuggled in their beds. Except my mother. This is post the peeling of the skin, multiple drug-resistant bacterial infections, etc detailed earlier. They sat her up in a chair. She cannot walk by herself and is a heavy woman with back problems and in a few hours is groaning in pain. She cannot get back to bed. Finally one nurse tries to get her into bed by herself and drops her on the floor. She can’t lift her up by herself so my mother lies on the floor for about an hour while she finds an orderly to help her.
2005 Westchester Medical Center-yes she is still here. Screaming in pain as she now has Clostridium dificile in her gut. I fight daily to get the pain management team to come in and address her pain or sedate her so she does not know she has it. They are afraid it will affect her breathing, do a minimal amount, and daily my mother begs me to kill her so she won’t feel anymore pain.
2005 Columbia Preysbaterian Post Quadrple bypass. My mother is told to get out of bed by the X ray tech and stand against the wall. She says she can’t. He gets her out of bed, pushes her against the wall for a standing X-ray, and as she told him she would, falls on the fall, on top of her surgical wound (which was reopend and re-sewn shut after the initial surgery. This causes great pain for a long period of time. The wound is disturbed during the pulling of her up from the floor. The bones no longer meet properly. The hospital files this under..shit happens. Later in her attempts at recovery, she develops a major infection of the wound and chest. This requires a second surgery. It is after this surgery that she developes chronic care myopathy and never comes off the venilator, is on dialysis and has a feeding tube permantly installed in her stomach surgically. I wonder if her wound had initally not been disturbed with this fall if she might not have gotten this infection.
Later in the year, back again at St. Luke’s Hospital, in Newburgh, New York, mother is transported from her nursing home, still on a ventilator, with a fever and infection. She is given an antibiotic to which she has an allergy. On her wrist she wears a medic alert bracelet that lists it as an allergy. She was also in that hospital two weeks previously and her charts also listed this as something that she is allergic to and that when she has an allergic reaction, it is extremely severe. I really think she might have had a chance at survival if they hadn’t made error after error after error to further insult her already weak body.
And I simply do not have the energy to list all the other little things that happend. For instance she was in a nursing home in August, it was over 85 degrees in her room. They took away her fan because they claimed it was a safety issue. In order to recieve medicare and medicaid coverage the highest temperature a room can be in the summer is 80 degrees.
Go to the others posts on Death, and Death and Dying and you will see more gory details.
But the undercurrent behind this, is, if this is what happened to one person, all of this, what is happening overall? I wanted to prevent someone else from goign through this.
So I complained to the New York State Department of Health. I gave them all the details. Even though the hospital investigation bureau is only one floor beneath me, and I work for a county health department, they would not meet with me face to face but only talk via the telephone or fax. I had faith that they would do something to prevent this from happening again. SIX MONTHS after filing my initial complaint they wrote to me to say they could find nothing was done wrong at all and that they could not even tell me the details of the investigations because of HIPPA rulings. I was my mother’s health care proxy and had her power of attorney and yet they would tell me nothing.
OK so I decide to go to a lawyer. I need my mothers medical records. It takes me three months to get them calling the hospital every single day. Here is the catch. A municipal hospital, such as Westchester Medical Center must be sued within three months of the patients release. It took me three months alone to get my records! And I do wonder about the political ramifications of Westchester Medical Center being government affiliated and the New York Department of State’s failure to find any wrong doing here, and the length of time it took them to get back to me.
But OK I get to a lawyer. The first lawyer Greg Bagen, who thought I had a case against Westchester Medical Center, if the filing date had not past, declined to take the case for that reason. I could still sue the medical doctor involved, The slimy sarcastic Dr. Cohen of the Cardiac Cath lab, who by the way, joked the entire way though my mother’s procedure making sarcastic comments on to his staff on how they would be doing twice the work and twice the patients with half the staff due to Medical Center Budget cuts…
So I go to the second lawyer. First I go back to Greg Bagen’s office to get my mother’s records. They give me a box that seems light and assure me it is everything I gave them. It turns out in the several months they were reviewing the records a second important filing date had passed and if we filed we might be able to make some sort of appeal to still get a case in…but I really had a better case against the first lawyer for letting these dates past. The second lawyer also thought the records were incomplete. OK…so I decide I can’t sue. I don’t want to sue because I want money, I want the hospital to straighten up and fly right.
Last week (this is months and months after I went to the second lawyer who partially based on the medical records didn’t take the case) I get a letter from Greg Bagen that is he declining the case but he still has my mother’s medical records. I call them up and told them of my previous visit and that they told me I had all the records then…..
The secretary refused to deal with it and said she would take a message and yes there was a big box of my mother’s medical records there….
I never got a call back or an explaination.
One of the reasons the second lawyer didn’t take the case was explained to me by the fact that it cost him $30,000 to prepare and file for a case. If the case could not promise a $300,000 return, because of the tight regulation on medical malpractice lawyers, he could not take the case. In fact it pretty much had to be an almost guarenteed case for him, otherwise he couldn’t stay in practice. And additionally to that many states are putting caps on the amount of awards that can be given.
So am I mad? Yes I am. Very. And I haven’t quit yet. I want to know who regulates the regulators, who let’s Westchester Medical Center take 3 months to get medical records to you when that is your filing deadline, I want to know why the New York State Department of Health takes 6 months to find NOTHING. I want to know if the reason they found nothing was because Westchester Medical Center was a government enterprise and they are a government entity. Can a regulator regulate itself? I want to know why hospital administrators only try to make things go away and not try to effect change. I want to know why St. Luke’s Hospital, when my mother was recieving medical treatment and her medical doctor stated it was necessary that she remain in a hospital was able to cancel her medicare payments and put her on private pay at three times the rate when I would not let her go to a subactute ventilator/dialysis facility so far away the family could not be with her and one that would also be detrimental to her health and treatment. All of these things seem to be at best unethical and I cannot imagine do not violate laws of fraud and more.
Hospitals are money making enterprises. The almightly dollar is first and avoiding liability is second. They love boutique enterprizes like joint surgery clinics that are cash cows and hate having do things that actually serve the community and are dependent on medicare payments.
The lowest degree of error and death by medical malpractice is in Great Britain at the moment. A country with socialized medicine. Perhaps its time to kill the medical cash cow.